Pegasus Pizza West Seattle

Pizza Restaurant in the West Seattle Junction. Catering, Lunch and Dinner.

Discover

Our Menu Categories

We moved to West Seattle Junction!

Pegasus Pizza is now in the West Seattle Junction at 4520 California Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98116!

Great to try

Chef Recommends

  • $

    HOUSE (TOM’S) SPECIAL

    • Small - $
    • Medium - $
    • Large - $

    Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Olives, Feta and Mozzarella Cheese, fresh Garlic, Diced Tomatoes, Spinach, Sunflower Seeds and Topped with Shredded Pepperoni

  • $

    THE GREEK

    • Small - $
    • Medium - $
    • Large - $

    Feta and Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Spinach, Olives, Onions, Ground Beef & Sunflower Seeds

  • ROSE PENNE

    Chicken, Italian Link Sausage and Mushrooms in our Rose Sauce

  • BAKED MANICOTTI

    Two large Pasta Rolls filled with a blend of Cheeses baked in Meat Sauce and smothered with Mozzarella Cheese

  • Spaghetti with Meat Balls

  • $

    Greek Salad

    • half - $
    • full - $

    A wonderful meal or split one before your Pizza, Feta Cheese, Sliced Onions and Green Peppers, Olives, Mushrooms, Sunflower Seeds, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Greek Olives, Greek Peppers, Artichoke Hearts and tossed with our own house dressing.

View Full Menu

Random Dishes

From Our Menu

  • Side of Sauce

    Choice of marinera, alfredo or pizza.

  • Pesto Bread

    Garlic cheese bread with pesto sauce.

  • Feta Bread

    Feta, mozzarella cheese and sunflower seeds.

  • Cheese Bread

    Melted cheese on delicious bread.

  • Garlic Bread

    Delicious fresh garlic bread.

  • $

    Soup of the Day

    • Cup - $
    • Bowl - $

    House made soup.

View Full Menu

Call Us: (206) 932-4849

What Our Clients Say

Testimonials

Pegasus Pizza is an Alki institution. The pizza to order here is the Tom’s Special, which is their version of an “everything” pizza. The shredded pepperoni on top is so good!! My mouth is watering right now as I write this review…  highly recommend this place.

Jenny

Just moved into the area and was looking for some where nice to get pizza or pasta. Got a Toms Special Pizza based on previous reviews and was utterly blown away.. its incredible and I highly recommend. Very unique and not like any pizza I have have before but in a very good way! Dough, toppings were utterly amazing.

Keith

This was my first time eating here while visiting Seattle. Absolutely loved it! Their pizza is layered just right and tastes amazing. Something as simple  as a meat lovers pizza tastes great. Looking forward to visiting again. Highly recommend!

S.M.

This place is fantastic! The food is Amazing. Wonderful atmosphere. Our Server was so informative on all the great things on their menue. Karl goes above and beyond. A must go to place to enjoy your night.

Stacey

You guys have to try Tom’s Pizza, it is amazing! The shredded pepperoni is such a nice touch. Great ambiance and food, awesome service and fast for a Saturday night rush. A great find in Alki Beach!

Lucy

Hands down the best pizza! When I am in town, Pegasus is one of my stops. I always order the veggie pizza. The pizza is topped with sunflower seeds.

Joyce

Had a great lunch here on Sunday! Bloodys were great and pizza was absolutely delicious! Tried both the house and the Chipotle Pesto.

Courtney

Amazing pizza. Amazing owners. Great staff. I consider their Greek pizza one of the best pizzas ever. Especially for topping lovers. Great texture. Wonderful flavor.

Turok D.

Amazing pizza!!! Friendly service. And beautiful water view. What more do you need to know. Indoor and outdoor seating.

Tawney S.